Both Cape Cod and Martha’s Vineyard islands are situated in Massachusetts. Cape Cod has more public beaches and a higher summer population density, while Martha’s Vineyard provides a quieter vacation. Cape Cod has a cooler summer climate while Martha’s Vineyard has slightly warmer summers.
If you are planning to visit the islands, the ideal time is between May and September for pleasant weather. However, you should know that Cape Cod is more affordable than Martha’s Vineyard.
There are more factors you need to consider while choosing between Cape Cod and Martha’s Vineyard. Give this article a complete read to learn all the details.
Cape Cod Vs Martha’s Vineyard: A Brief Comparison
Cape Cod and Martha’s Vineyard are both popular tourist destinations. Thousands of visitors come to both locations every year.
In this section, we will have a quick glimpse of the necessary factors. They will also help you decide between Mt Baldy vs Big Bear or Tampa vs Miami.
| Factor | Cape Cod | Martha’s Vineyard |
| Location | Southeast Massachusetts on Cape Cod Bay | Off the coast of Massachusetts |
| Where to stay | -Vineyard Square Hotel & Suites
-Harbor Hotel Provincetown -Cape Sands Inn -Blue Water Resort |
-Vineyard Square Hotel & Suites
-Mansion House Inn -Hotel Admiralty Inn and Suites -Holiday Inn Cape Cod-Falmouth |
| Beaches | –Massive Variety of beaches (more than 60 beaches) | -Less variety of beaches than Cape Cod |
| Climate & Atmosphere | -Temperate climate with four distinct seasons.
–Cooler climate than Matha’s Vineyard |
-Temperate climate with four distinct seasons
-Less cooler than Martha’s Vineyard |
| Dining & Restaurants | -Clam shacks to upscale restaurants
-Known for its local seafood |
-Known for its fresh seafood |
| Activities | -Enjoying the beaches
-Exploring hiking trails, scenic views, and historical sites -Visiting museums -Whale watching, fishing, -Kayaking, or paddleboarding |
-Enjoying the beaches
-Exploring the nature preserves -Visiting museums -Fishing |
| Best time to visit | May to September | May to September |
| Cost | Relatively cheaper | Bit expensive |
Cape Cod Vs Martha’s Vineyard: An Elaborated Comparison
This is the most valuable section, where you will be able to make an informed decision based on detailed information.
Location
Cape Cod extends from the southeast coast of Massachusetts. On the other hand, Martha’s Vineyard is an island situated just 3 nautical miles off the Massachusetts coastline.
The proximity of Cape Cod and Martha’s Vineyard airports is evident. Cape Cod’s nearest airport is Barnstable Municipal Airport (HYA), and Martha’s Vineyard’s closest is Martha’s Vineyard Airport (MVY).
Travel options between these locations encompass bus, ferry, car ferry, car, and plane.
Where to Stay
Vineyard Square Hotel & Suites welcomes tourists from both Cape Cod and Martha’s Vineyard.
In Cape Cod, tourists can enjoy their stay in a wide range of luxurious and wonderful hotels. The popular options are:
- Harbor Hotel Provincetown,
- Cape Sands Inn
- Blue Water Resort
- Cape Codder Resort & Spa
- Best Western Cape Cod Hotel
- Cape Cod Harbor House Inn
- Platinum Pebble Boutique Inn
On the other hand, the popular option of staying in Martha’s Vineyard includes:
- Vineyard Square Hotel & Suites
- Mansion House Inn
- Hotel Admiralty Inn and Suites
- Holiday Inn Cape Cod-Falmouth
- Falmouth Inn
- Pequot
- Charlotte Inn
Beaches
Cape Cod boasts over 60 public beaches, notably Coast Guard National Beach within Cape Cod National Seashore. In contrast, Martha’s Vineyard offers fewer beaches compared to Cape Cod.
The top beaches for tourists in Cape Cod are:
- Nauset Beach
- Craigville Beach
- And Sandy Neck Beach.
In contrast, Martha’s Vineyard has some of the best beaches. The popular options are:
- Joseph Sylvia State Beach
- South Beach
- And Menemsha Beach.
Cape Cod has more public beaches and a higher summer population density, while Martha’s Vineyard provides a quieter vacation with fewer visitors.
Climate & Atmosphere
Cape Cod experiences a cooler summer climate, with average daily temperatures around 68°F (20°C) in July. Conversely, Martha’s Vineyard enjoys slightly warmer summers, with daily temperatures hovering around 73°F (23°C) in July.
Cape Cod offers beautiful autumn with color-changing leaves. Then it remains warmer in winter, and cooler in summer. Tourists can enjoy a vibrant atmosphere, activities, nightlife, and better beaches.
In contrast, Martha’s Vineyard’s winters are very cold (28°F/-2°C in January). A tranquil environment, diverse culture, and rich history make this place a great place to visit. The place attracts fewer tourists, making it ideal for peaceful vacations.
Dining & Restaurant
Cape Cod has abundant dining choices, from clam shacks to upscale restaurants. In contrast, Martha’s Vineyard has fewer dining options compared to Cape Cod, but diverse restaurants offer excellent food.
In terms of top restaurants, Cape Cod has the following:
- The Regatta of Cotuit
- The Curvee
- 28 Atlantic
- Bramble Inn and Restaurant
- Ross’ Grill.
On the other hand, notable restaurants of Martha’s Vineyard are:
- Mansion House Inn
- Hotel Admiralty Inn and Suites
- Holiday Inn Cape Cod-Falmouth
- Falmouth Inn, Pequot
- Charlotte Inn
- Among the Flowers Cafe
Activities
Cape Cod offers a variety of activities suitable for all ages, making it a family-friendly destination. In contrast, Martha’s Vineyard is ideal for those seeking a tranquil and serene vacation.
The most famous things to do in Cape Cod are:
- Exploring Beaches: Coast Guard National Beach, Nauset Beach, Craigville Beach, Sandy Neck Beach.
- Visiting museums: Cape Cod Museum of Natural History, John F. Kennedy Hyannis Museum, Heritage Museums & Gardens.
- Joining lively festivals and events like Cape Cod Scallop Fest, Provincetown Carnival, and Wellfleet OysterFest.
There are many things to do at Martha’s Vineyard. Most Notable are:
- Relaxing on beaches: Joseph Sylvia State Beach, South Beach, Menemsha Beach.
- Preserving Nature: Felix Neck Wildlife Sanctuary, Polly Hill Arboretum.
- Exploring Museum: Martha’s Vineyard Museum, Aquinnah Cultural Center, Gay Head Lighthouse.
Best Time to Visit
For both Cape Cod and Martha’s Vineyard, the prime visiting period falls between May and September.
This time Atlantic Ocean maintains temperatures below the 70s, offering clear and delightful weather.
To steer clear of substantial crowds, opt for May, June, September, or October. During these months, the climate remains pleasant, enhancing outdoor enjoyment, with fewer visitors and more budget-friendly rates.
Cost
In Cape Cod, the average daily cost per person is $183 while the average daily cost per person is $241 in Martha’s Vineyard.
Cape Cod offers diverse accommodation options at varying prices. In this place, tourists can get a mix of free and paid activities. On the other hand,
Martha’s Vineyard is a more generally upscale destination. It also offers diverse accommodation options at varying prices.
So, Which Is the Better One: Cape Cod Vs Martha’s Vineyard?
If you are looking for a more budget-friendly, variety of accommodations and dining options, Cape Cod would be a perfect option match for you.
A luxurious destination with a high average daily cost, Martha’s Vineyard would be your choice if you are looking for a luxury destination. It caters to those looking for a serene and upscale vacation.
Choosing Cape Cod is the ideal path if you seek activities for all ages, increased nightlife choices, superior beaches, and a more cost-effective lifestyle.
However, if a tranquil and secluded way of life appeals to you, Martha’s Vineyard might be the perfect fit.
Conclusion
Now, you know the difference between Cape Cod and Martha’s Vineyard.
Both destinations are worth exploring if time permits. Ultimately, the better choice depends on your budget and the type of vacation experience you’re seeking.
